How to Change a Water Heater Anode Rod the First Time (My Mistakes)

I have two Rheem water heaters, a Performance that’s about four years old and a Performance Platinum that’s about seven years old. This was my first time changing the sacrificial anode rods, and I was curious what condition they’d be in after that long. I found out a few things by first doing some things wrong, so save yourself some time and learn from my mistakes. It all worked out in the end.

I’m a homeowner, not a plumber, and this is simply my experience on my heaters. Follow your manufacturer’s instructions, follow at your own risk, and use proper safety precautions.

Before You Begin: Shut It Down and Drain a Little

Turn off the cold water supply and set the gas control to the pilot position so the burner won’t fire while you work. Then drain some water from the tank drain. I used an old garden hose I kept for this purpose, and had a bucket handy just in case.

On these Rheem units the anode is right there on top, so there’s nothing to pull out of the way to reach it.

Tools & Materials Used

Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you choose to buy through them, it helps support my work at no additional cost to you.

  • Ozek 44″ magnesium flexible anode rod https://amzn.to/3ztmt3l
  • Flexible magnesium anode rod, 3/4″ NPT hex plug, 4 segments, 44″ long https://amzn.to/3TwB6d1
  • Impact wrench, socket and a universal joint (for the heater with the exhaust hood right above it)
  • A regular ratchet
  • Teflon tape
  • Old garden hose and a bucket
  • Something to cut the rod (for trimming the last segment)

Step 1: Break the Old Anode Loose

The first heater has the exhaust hood right above the anode, so I used the impact wrench through a universal joint. It wouldn’t budge on the lower settings. I had to go up from medium to high before it started moving. The old rod was definitely in need of replacement, and that was after only four years.

Step 2: Tape and Feed In the New Rod

The new rod was longer than the one that came out. I wrapped Teflon tape around the threads, following the direction of the thread, which is counterclockwise if you’re looking down on the top. Because the rod is in sections, it’s very easy to feed in one segment at a time.

Mistake #1: I hadn’t drained enough water, and feeding the rod in displaced the water up to the top. Drain a bit more before you go any further.

Step 3: Snug It Up and Check the Pilot

I started tightening with the impact on its very lowest setting, then turned the gas control back from pilot to on. One important safety check: make sure the pilot light is still on before you walk away.

Step 4: Fix the Leak

Mistake #2: When I turned the water back on, there was some leaking at the anode. I turned the water off again, set it back to pilot, drained a little more to relieve pressure, and tightened it with a regular ratchet instead of going through the universal joint. It’s deceptive how much force you’re putting on it through that joint. I read that you only need about 8 foot-pounds, but since it leaked before I made sure it was snug.

Step 5: Trim the Rod So It Doesn’t Sit on the Bottom

Mistake #3: Even though everything was installed and fine, the 44-inch rod was resting on the bottom of the tank. My intuition said it’s not a good idea to have the anode touching the inside of the tank, and some people online seem to agree, although there isn’t much information about it. So I went through the shutdown again, took the rod out (easy this time with a regular ratchet, since it was just installed), cut off the last segment, re-taped it and screwed it back in.

Step 6: Service the Second Heater

The seven-year-old Performance Platinum followed the same procedure: pilot position, water supply off, drain a little, then break the anode loose with the impact on high. This one was more accessible, and I learned that if you take the plastic part out, you can grab the anode directly. Surprisingly there was still something left of the old rod after seven years, but it was breaking apart and some of it stayed inside the tank. Then I taped the new rod and tightened it with the ratchet, snug enough to seal but not over-tight.

Final Thoughts: Stainless vs Carbon Steel Cable

The two flexible rods I bought are built differently. The Ozek uses what looks like a stainless steel cable between the sections, while the other uses what looks like carbon steel. My concern is how long that carbon steel cable will last before it rusts through, so to me the stainless one looks like the better idea. If you’re diligent and change your anodes often, it may not matter and the least expensive one could do a good job. I may take these out again in a few years to see how they held up. While you’re working on your heater, you might also want to see how I replaced the plastic drain valve with brass.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *